Happy Birthday, Jay DeMarcus! The Rascal Flatts superstar celebrates 41 years today (April 26), and we know it’s bound to be a good day for him. After all, the Flatts just released their chart-topping new album, ‘Changed,’ at the beginning of his birthday month, ‘Banjo’ is a huge hit with fans and radio alike, and DeMarcus and his wife are expecting their second child — a boy — this summer. Could life get any better?

In order to help him celebrate, today’s Taste of Country Readers Poll asks you, what’s your favorite Rascal Flatts song? We selected just a handful of the group’s most popular hits for you to choose from, mixing a few old ones with some fresh tunes. But if you’re in love with a song that didn’t make the cut, feel free to tell us in the comments section below!